*** The following post is MY opinion and no one else’s. I am not speaking for the sex blogging community***
There was a day, about a year and a half ago, when Sylvanus still lived in the small apartment. We had just begun our journey together and blogging about it on one shared blog. We were (and happily still are) a small speck in the sex blogging sphere. We wrote because we loved to and that’s how we met. We wrote to share our feelings to our readers and ourselves. We wrote to share our happiness and to give others hope. We wrote to be that breath of fresh air in a blogging world so full of drama.
About a year and a half ago, I remember reading a few “well known” blogs and seeing that they were reviewing sex toys. I remember looking at Sylvanus and saying to him, “Wouldn’t it be cool, if one day, our blog became well known enough that people would ask us to review for them? I mean how cool would it be that we could get free toys and all we had to do was review them?”
It wasn’t until 6 months ago that we were given the chance to do just that. Isn’t it interesting how times have changed? Back then it seemed only a few companies were reaching out to sex bloggers and only to the ones that were getting a lot of traffic and considered exceptional writers. Today, well, there are many more companies doing this now and everyone has a chance to take advantage of their generosity.
From all these reviews that have developed, it was only natural that a “best of” list would be created. When I first heard word of such a list being composed, I thought “Cool, I wonder who they will pick?” Sylvanus and I knew we didn’t have a chance. We just weren’t big enough. BUT we didn’t care.
We watched as blogs around us posted the announcement of this list being created. They threw in a few words about “vote for me!” But Sylvanus and I remained silent. We didn’t care. In fact we quietly composed in our head the list of people who would win.
And wouldn’t you know, they were all at the top of the list?
We are pretty good aren’t we? How about I tell you that I have never read any of these blogs? I would have no clue that their reviews are “the best of the best”.
So how was I able to pull 5 names out of the air and name them as being the top? Yes, that’s right, popularity. See these lists aren’t actually about the best.. but it’s all about who you know. OK Ok.. Let me stop there.. I am NOT saying that the people who did make it to the top of the list did NOT deserve it.
I think the list was a fine idea, but it was badly executed.
Firstly, the people who decided to make the list were also able to include themselves in the “voting”. Hey, that’s cool, why deny yourselves a chance at being the best? But if you are going to do that, why not pitch your idea to an outsider? Have them handle the list and put it together. A third party was asked to handle the scoring for the creators of the list, but really? Do you honestly think you are going to be thrown at the bottom of the list when you asked someone to score you?
Secondly, all blogs being considered had to have done a review at some point in 2008. They were then scored on a scale of one to five in four areas: Content, Organization, Originality, and Regularity. Nominations were also taken into consideration when ties in scoring occurred. (Again, sooo.. you can see how being “popular” helps in the extra scores here right?)
Thirdly, *I* (again I cannot emphasize more here that I made the assumption) assumed the list would be 5 maybe 10 people long. Just a simple little list of who is considered “the best”. But it wasn’t. The list ended up being 75 people strong. The list was intended to rank everyone they could think of (I think).
I think that was a poor decision. Sylvanus and I were happy not being on the list. We never wanted to be on the list, we never thought we had a chance. But then, the list comes out and it’s 75 people strong and we are on it.. at number 72. Now we feel insulted.
I don’t know how the rating system went. I don’t know what was the difference between someone at 42 versus 72.. but Sylvanus and I took a step back and thought.. really?
I sat back and thought, well, one of the factors of rating was regularity. OK, so we have kind of fell of the map on regularity. We haven’t been consistent at all lately. So, there was our downfall.. oh but wait.. there are people in the 40′s who have not reviewed in a really long time and no longer review at all. Hmm that’s not it then.
Then I just look at all the different names on the list. Yes, a lot deserving of their rank. But then I look at a few, much higher up than us, and wonder how could that be? These people write short reviews, maybe just a paragraph long. They take crappy pictures of the product with their cell phones or no pictures at all.
And these people get put above us?
Sylvanus and I have always taken pride of everything we write here. Our reviews are one of them. We started writing reviews of our toys, all on our own. Just because we wanted to. Then, when we were first approached by a company to review products, we were thrilled and so grateful for their generosity. We wanted to make sure to do them right in our reviews. If a product sucked, we said so. If it was great, we raved about it. We even had fun doing product comparison.
We devoted a lot of time and energy into our reviews. Sylvanus more so than I. He took multiple pictures of the product and wrote up a whole outline of our reviews that started with packaging, appearance, materials and finally putting it to work. Our reviews were not paragraphs thrown into the wind. It consisted of his opinion as well as mine. You got a couples view of a product. Perhaps, this is where we went wrong. Obviously, devoting that much time into a review would make someone burn out after awhile AND clearly, putting that much effort into a review counts for nothing (in some people’s eyes).
Eh, perhaps our reviews just aren’t entertaining enough.
Anyways, there’s my rant. I have been biting my tongue on this since the list came out and thought I was so over it, until today. Really, I think a “best of” list on anything is really not a “best of” list. Any list created by bloggers on bloggers is bound to be influenced by who knows who. It’s the lists done by outsiders that really count in my opinion. Which is why Sylvanus and I never care to join the drama.
I need to be perfectly clear. This is NOT a jealous rant saying that Sylvanus and I should have been number 1 . Oh god no. Congrats to all at the top of the list. We were pleased to see our friends Freddy and Eddy hit number 19 ( but really, they deserved so much more than 19. This is their lively hood. This is their expertise. They make videos on how to use the products for gawd sakes and are currently trying to revolutionize the whole industry. But can’t complain too much considering they are not sex bloggers) and couldn’t help but chuckle when they said “so and so didn’t make the list? Their reviews are AWESOME!” and “I can’t believe that person even made it on the list!” I personally, value their opinion deeply. I had to remind them that it was just a list created by sex bloggers for sex bloggers.
But this is a post stating that “best of” lists really should be carefully thought out. Otherwise good intentions can turn out to be insults or just turn out bad.
I have purposefully not linked to anyone here (except Freddy and Eddy). This isn’t a personal attack on anyone and so I don’t need to link to specific people. There have been a lot of posts going around about the subject of toy reviewing in the sex blogging world. We even wrote a post about toys in general not too long ago and in fact, I will link to Sylvanus’s post right now so that you can follow what he had to say and then read what others had to say.
So there you have it.. my two cents. I’m sure I’ve made people angry, but hey, it’s just my opinion. Perhaps I spoke up for you, perhaps I didn’t. What does it matter when you are but one tiny speck in the entire universe?
*** please take a moment to read the comment stream. There have been additional thoughts made by both Sylvanus and myself as well as readers. For once, a comment stream here is worth the read. ***